Hello dear
Welcome To Brother's Pizza Gettysburg
At Brother's Pizza Gettysburg, the charm of a local eatery meets a rich selection of delectable pies and hearty subs, all housed in a former bank. This beloved spot is celebrated for its friendly service and inviting atmosphere, perfect for families and sports enthusiasts alike. Patrons rave about the authentic cheesesteaks, mouthwatering pizzas featuring their signature “squeaky cheese,” and standout appetizers like marinara-dipped mozzarella sticks. With options for outdoor seating and quick delivery, Brother's Pizza is a go-to destination for anyone looking to enjoy high-quality, comfort food in Gettysburg. Join us to savor the flavors that keep customers coming back!
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Ham Cheese
Stuffed Shells
White Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch
About
Brother's Pizza Gettysburg
Welcome to Brother's Pizza Gettysburg, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Gettysburg, PA. Located conveniently at 14 W Hanover St, this local favorite serves up more than just delicious pizza; it offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that keeps patrons coming back for more. Whether you're a pizza aficionado or simply on the hunt for a hearty meal, Brother's Pizza promises an experience that delights both the palate and spirit.
Immerse yourself in the unique ambiance of a restaurant converted from a former bank, where the walls echo stories of the past while aromas of freshly baked pizza fill the air. Customers rave about the authenticity of their dishes, particularly noting that the crust strikes the perfect balance—not too thick, not too thin. The signature mozzarella sticks paired with the heavenly marinara sauce are a must-try, making for a delightful starter or a savory companion to your main course.
- Popular Menu Items:
- Classic Pizzas: Each bite showcases quality ingredients and a dedication to traditional pizza-making.
- Cold Subs: The Italian Sub and Cheesesteaks receive high praise for their robust flavors and generous portions.
- Specialty Options: Try the grilled chicken Caesar wrap if you’re looking for something lighter that doesn’t compromise on taste.
- Friendly Service: The staff at Brother's Pizza are known for their warm hospitality. As one customer noted, every visit is met with a friendly greeting, enhancing the overall dining experience.
- Family Friendly: Perfect for gatherings, the lively environment often features sports games, making it an ideal spot for families and friends to relax together.
As you gather around the table with loved ones, the variety of offerings will surely satisfy everyone’s cravings—from their rich and cheesy pizzas to the wholesome subs. Feedback from patrons like Jordan N. highlights the quality and freshness of the food, making it evident that Brother’s Pizza is not just about serving meals, but creating unforgettable memories around the dining table.
With its accessible location, friendly vibe, and dedicated attention to quality, Brother's Pizza Gettysburg is destined to become your go-to pizza joint. Experience all the delightful flavors they have to offer on your next visit—we guarantee you'll be glad you did!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ We have passed by this restaurant dozens of times, and finally made it a point to stop here. It's a cute little restaurant that could probably use a face-lift but it was clean inside at least. The mozzarella sticks were delicious but the marinara dipping sauce was heavenly. We were even dipping our pizza crust in that sauce! We were warmly greeted (both coming and going) by one of the employees. The only gripe I might have is that their fountain drinks had a slightly strange taste to them, which is typical for using the local water sources. There are plenty of other things I want to try on the menu, so I know we will be back soon. ”
“ Authentic delicious made pizza in a former bank. I guarantee soccer is playing when you arrive. Perfect for the extended family wanting a few slices of pizza, drinks and watching the game. Very quick turnaround on the order. The pictures of the pizza say it all. ”
“ I can not say enough how absolutely delicious the cheesesteak and Italian subs were that we bought today! The staff was friendly, the service was quick and the restaurant was clean and not run down. I didn't think to take pics because I anticipated it to be the same as every other sub shop. Stop in and give them a try! ”
“ Wonderful food, friendly service. Our family of 8 came to eat outside and got two large pizzas , a small white pizza , a bunch of mozzarella sticks & a ceaser wrap. All delicious , hot , fresh . Everyone was happy! ”
“ The pizza here is great! Not too thick, not too thin. And you absolutely must have the squeaky cheese! They are little fried cheese curds of heaven. My husband loves the cheese steak here as well. And if your looking for something on the light side, the grilled chicken caesar wrap is super tasty! ”
“ Brother's offers a casual atmosphere and great prices. I've only ever tried their pizza and it is greasy and delicious! ”
“ Great cheesesteak special! Love their own made rolls and the sauce on the special. Pizza is ok, family likes it and it's very convenient to our location. Always friendly and good service. ”
“ This pizzeria opened a few months ago in Bonneauville and it could not have done so a minute to soon. The town has very limited options as it was (no actual restaurants), but that's not to say Brothers is good because its the only game in town. With my wife's love of all things pizza I have no doubt that she would make us drive over an hour to get a slice. However we are both very happy with this location. The owner is very nice to chat with and they make great food. The pizzas are top notch and the make all their own bread for subs. I forsee us going to this Brothers Pizza for a long time to come. ”
